EBVs Are No Bull

August 30, 2017 11:34 am


EBVs Are No Bull

Lessons from the Angus Sire Benchmarking Program

The value of Estimated Breeding Values (EBVs) and Selection Indexes has been explored in a joint project between Angus Australia and the MLA Donor Company (MDC).

Angus TACE Project Officer, Miss Ashleigh Horne said the project has emphasized the value of performance recording, genetic evaluation and selection in the seedstock industry.

The project has shown that EBVs are reliable indicators of the genetic merit of each animal.

“Using informative tools such as EBVs and Selection Indexes, producers are able to readily select animals with superior genetics, subsequently increasing the rate of genetic gain in their herd and achieving long term sustainable genetic improvement”, Miss Horne said.

“Australian Angus producers have been dedicated to collecting quality performance data on a regular basis. To see proof that EBVs are doing a good job is such an encouragement. It reinforces that each producer’s investment of time, effort and money into collecting quality information is worthwhile”, said Miss Horne.

The project used data sourced from the first three cohorts of the Angus Sire Benchmarking Project (ASBP), encompassing approximately 40 sires joined to 2000 cows per cohort (25 progeny per sire).



Several key concepts were explored, including the amount of genetic variation between Angus bulls, and whether the EBVs of young Angus bulls are accurately predicting the performance of their progeny.

“The project demonstrated there was great opportunity to make genetic improvement through careful bull selection, with considerable differences being observed in the progeny from different bulls.”

For example, the progeny from the highest 5 performing sires for yearling weight had progeny that were on average 35 Kgs heavier than the progeny from the 5 lowest performing sires. At a sale price of $3.00/Kg, this equates to a difference of $105 per animal.

Similarly, the project demonstrated that the EBVs of sires when entered in the ASBP reliably predicted the subsequent performance of their progeny.

We found that most sires will perform as predicted by their EBV, and while some individual sires may perform better or worse than predicted, the EBVs will on average, provide a reliable indicator of the genetics that sires are delivering to a breeding herd.

Angus Sire Benchmarking Program Chairman, Ross Thompson said that as someone who has been supplying bulls since the beginning of the project, it was terrific to see that the TACE model is surprisingly accurate across the average Angus population.

Detailed outcomes from this project can be found under the ‘Lessons from the ASBP’ menu located under ‘Sire Benchmarking’ located in the main menu bar above.


Feature Image: Angus Australia’s Project Officer – BREEPLAN, Ashleigh Horne has been working on a project jointly funded by Angus Australia and the MLA Donor Company (MDC) to demonstrate the value of the selection tools provided by Angus Australia.